Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisorHayes, Dennis
dc.contributor.authorHaden-Walker, James
dc.identifier.citationHaden-Walker, J. (2019). 'What makes Geography a worthwhile school subject? An exploration of the current controversy in geography teaching'. Unpublished EdD Thesis. University of Derby.
dc.description.abstractGeography as a school subject is in controversy. This controversy is given expression in an on-going debate between the opposing views of two leading academics Alex Standish and David Lambert. The Standish/Lambert debate reflects the discussion by the philosopher Paul Hirst in the 1960s of the nature of geography as a ‘field’ of knowledge rather and an independent ‘form’ of knowledge. The ‘field’ that is geography is said by Standish (2007) to be politicised while Lambert (2009) argues that this is just geography in modern form. In this dissertation Standish, Lambert and other leading geographers were interviewed to explore the nature of their disagreement and how it relates to what Michael Young (2007) has described as the need to give all pupils ‘powerful knowledge’. In addition to interviews with experts and teachers, this study carried out a questionnaire of geography teachers in Staffordshire. This study found that this dispute in the academic world reflected real divisions in what teachers understood as the value and nature of geography. Some teachers saw knowledge, or skills, as more relevant while others emphasised values and attitudes. They had a varied range of views relating to geographical knowledge and the impact of wider environmental issues alongside concerns over time allocation for the subject and its hierarchical position in relation to other ‘core’ subjects such as Mathematics, Science, and English. The study concluded that geography will remain in controversy until the Standish/Lambert debate is more fully discussed and debated among teachers. This thesis is a contribution to that debate.en_US
dc.publisherUniversity of Derbyen_US
dc.rightsCC0 1.0 Universalen_US
dc.subjectField and forms of knowledge Hirsten_US
dc.subjectPowerful Knowledge Michael Youngen_US
dc.subjectAlex Standish David Lamberten_US
dc.subjectGeography Teachingen_US
dc.titleWhat makes Geography a worthwhile school subject? An exploration of the current controversy in geography teachingen_US
dc.typeThesis or dissertationen_US
dc.publisher.departmentPGR Studenten_US
dc.relation.referencesMajor, B.J. (2012) Geography, Knowledge and School Subjects in the Curriculum. A conceptual review of the literature, Educational and Social Research Dissertationen_US

Files in this item

What makes Geography a worthwhile ...
Microsoft Word 2007
What Makes Geography a worthwhile ...

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

CC0 1.0 Universal
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as CC0 1.0 Universal