Mental contrasting for health behaviour change: a systematic review and meta-analysis of effects and moderator variables
AffiliationUniversity of Derby
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractMental contrasting is a self-regulation imagery strategy that involves imagining a desired future and mentally contrasting it with the present reality, which is assumed to prompt the individual to realise that action is required to achieve the desired future. Research has combined mental contrasting with implementation intentions (MCII) (‘if-then’ plans), which is hypothesised to strengthen the effects. A systematic review was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of mental contrasting for improving health-related behaviours. A meta-analysis (N = 1528) using random effects modelling found a main effect of mental contrasting on health outcomes, adjusted Hedges’ g = 0.28 (SE = .07), 95% CI [0.13–0.43], p < .001 at up to four weeks, and an increased effect at up to three months (k = 5), g = 0.38 (SE = 0.6), CI [0.20–0.55], p < .001. The combination of mental contrasting with implementation intentions (MCII; k = 7) showed a similar effect, g = 0.28, CI [0.14–0.42], p < .001. Mental contrasting shows promise as a brief behaviour change strategy with a significant small to moderate-sized effect on changing health behaviour in the short-term. Analysis on a small subset of studies suggested that the addition of implementation intentions (MCII) did not further strengthen the effects of mental contrasting on health behaviours, although additional studies are needed.
CitationCross, A., and Sheffield, D. (2019) 'Mental contrasting for health behaviour change: a systematic review and meta-analysis of effects and moderator variables'. Health Psychology Review, 13(2), pp. 209-225. DOI: 10.1080/17437199.2019.1594332
PublisherTaylor and Francis
JournalHealth Psychology Review
- An online randomised controlled trial of mental contrasting with implementation intentions as a smoking behaviour change intervention.
- Authors: Mutter ER, Oettingen G, Gollwitzer PM
- Issue date: 2020 Mar
- Mental contrasting as a behaviour change technique: a systematic review protocol paper of effects, mediators and moderators on health.
- Authors: Cross A, Sheffield D
- Issue date: 2016 Nov 25
- Supporting Sustainable Food Consumption: Mental Contrasting with Implementation Intentions (MCII) Aligns Intentions and Behavior.
- Authors: Loy LS, Wieber F, Gollwitzer PM, Oettingen G
- Issue date: 2016
- From Fantasy to Action: Mental Contrasting with Implementation Intentions (MCII) Improves Academic Performance in Children.
- Authors: Duckworth AL, Kirby T, Gollwitzer A, Oettingen G
- Issue date: 2013 Nov 1
- A brief intervention to improve exercising in patients with schizophrenia: a controlled pilot study with mental contrasting and implementation intentions (MCII).
- Authors: Sailer P, Wieber F, Pröpster K, Stoewer S, Nischk D, Volk F, Odenwald M
- Issue date: 2015 Sep 3